Victor Davis Hanson
"When left and right finally agree on something, watch out: The unthinkable becomes normal.
"So it is with changing attitudes toward Silicon Valley.
"For the last two decades, Apple, Google, Amazon and other West Coast tech corporations have been
untouchable icons. They piled up astronomical profits while hypnotizing both left-wing and right-wing politicians.
"Conservative administrations praised them as modern versions of 19th-century risk-takers such as
Andrew Carnegie and John D. Rockefeller. Bill Gates, the late Steve Jobs and other tech giants were
seen as supposedly creating national wealth in an unregulated, laissez-faire landscape that they had
invented from nothing.
" At a time when American companies were increasingly unable to compete in the rough-and-tumble
world arena, Apple, Microsoft, and Facebook bulldozed their international competition. Indeed, they
turned high-tech and social media into American brands.
"The left was even more enthralled. It dropped its customary regulatory zeal, despite Silicon Valley's
monopolizing, outsourcing, offshoring, censoring, and destroying of startup competition. After all,
Big Tech was left-wing and generous. High-tech interests gave hundreds of millions of dollars to leftwing
candidates, think tanks and causes.
"Companies such as Facebook and Google were able to warp their own social media protocols and
Internet searches to insidiously favor progressive agendas and messaging.
"If the left feared that the tech billionaires were becoming robber barons, they also delighted in the
fact that they were at least left-wing robber barons.
"Unlike the steel, oil and coal monopolies of the 19th century that out of grime and smoke created the
sinews of a growing America, Silicon Valley gave us shiny, clean, green and fun pods, pads and
phones.
"As a result, social media, internet searches, texts, email and other computer communications were
exempt from interstate regulatory oversight. Big Tech certainly was not subject to the rules that
governed railroads, power companies, trucking industries, Wall Street, and television and radio.
"But attitudes about hip high-tech corporations have now changed on both the left and right." . . .
