"If we’re going to insist that ‘it takes a village,’ let’s agree that the government isn’t that village."
Aubrey Harris
"Any time the government shows up to our door and offers to help, we should be suspicious. Especially when it comes masquerading as our community."
"It takes a village,” I was assured even before my daughter was born.
A village to provide for a child. A village to help with the child. A village to educate the child. A village to instill morals into the child. For a phrase popularized by Hillary Clinton, nominally hailing from some remote place in the massive continent of Africa (no one is quite sure where), “it takes a village” certainly gets a lot of traction. At this point, saying the words feels akin to invoking some great and intractable rule of the universe.
"It wasn’t just the mom-themed social media posts my algorithm magically figured I needed to see — it was my mom, my sisters, the lovely women who came to my baby shower, and even the grandmas in the grocery-store checkout line.
"Presumably, most of us say “village” and mean something along the lines of “a community — friends or family — I’ve chosen and would trust with my life.” Statistically speaking, that kind of community is more dream than reality for most young families today. So, because nature abhors a vacuum, something must step into that community’s place.
"Enter Gov. Maura Healey of Massachusetts.
"Last week, the governor’s office published a proposal to allocate an additional $2 million to an existing program that sends nurses to mothers’ homes during their postpartum period with the aim of making that program universally available.
"The program wouldn’t be mandatory, by any means. Anyone who opted in would have a nurse stop by their home to answer questions about basic childcare, screen for postpartum depression and anxiety, and evaluate the home for risk factors like substance and physical abuse. The proposal also suggests allocating an additional $250,000 toward a program dedicated to addressing maternal mental health.
"All of this, of course, comes in the wake of the Lindsay Clancy trial.
"Whether Lindsay Clancy was suffering from postpartum psychosis when she killed her three children or not, the whole incident has led to a veritable storm of internet folk pontificating on the subject of postpartum mental health in the public sphere. Suddenly, we’ve decided postpartum anxiety, depression, and psychosis are national problems amounting to an epidemic caused by our society’s systemic failure to support mothers (a devastating side-effect of the patriarchy, the pink-clad hordes will tell you). (RELATED: Lindsay Clancy, Motherhood, and a Culture That Has Forgotten Sacrifice)
"Surely, the only remedy is yet another government program; specifically, a program that has the government inviting itself into your living room." . . .More.
Aubrey Harris is a graduate of Hillsdale College (2023), the former Intercollegiate Studies Institute fellow at The American Spectator and current columnist. She writes Spectator P.M. Newsletter for American Spectator subscribers where she rambles on current events, historical topics, and life in general. When she isn’t writing, Aubrey enjoys long runs, solving rock climbs, and rattling windows with the 32-foot pipes on the organ