"It troubles me that I even have to write this: A college or university cannot function if every academic obligation becomes negotiable whenever someone organizes a protest. Norms and rules must be clear, and they must mean something; schools must enforce consequences when expectations and rules are broken".
![]() |
| FIRE | Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression |
"Members of the Harvard Graduate Students Union–United Auto Workers (HGSU-UAW) are on strike at Harvard University, and the Harvard Crimson’s account of what happened outside Emerson Hall on Oct. 29 raises a far too familiar question about Harvard’s leadership: Why is protecting students’ education still treated as a matter of competing rights?
"The background to what is going on at Harvard is quite straightforward: Roughly 250 undergraduates were taking a midterm when striking graduate students gathered with megaphones, air horns, and sirens outside the lecture hall where the exam was being administered.
"According to the course professor, Dr. David Jones, the noise lasted for about 75 minutes. He had bought 100 pairs of earplugs and allowed noise-canceling headphones during the exam, but nothing helped. One student reportedly walked out after 15 minutes.
"Professor Jones, teaching Medical Ethics and History, later explained in an opinion piece for the Crimson that the union emailed him two days before the disruption, warning that its planned picket might interfere with his class. The union urged him to cancel or relocate his class, and Jones asked about other rooms, but none large enough were available. Postponing the test made little sense during an open-ended strike, and he ruled out a take-home exam because of generative AI.
"Jones says in his own account that he has always supported the union’s right to strike. After the exam, the HGSU sent an email to Jones’s class that blamed him for the disruption: “As fellow students, we recognize that exams are stressful enough without disruption. To avoid such disruption, HGSU leadership notified your instructor 48 hours in advance of our picketing plans and encouraged them to move the class. Unfortunately, they did not.”
"Jones was trying to perform his teaching duties, and Harvard should have made sure he could do so, without leaving him to find another classroom or hand out earplugs." . . . More.

